Hardeman Motorsport B.V. — Zandweg 20a, Kruiningen (NL) +31 (0)113 700266 info@hardemanmotorsport.nl

Comparing Limited-Slip Differentials

The demand for a limited-slip differential (LSD) originally arose in motorsport. When Ferdinand Porsche noticed that his Auto Union Silver Arrow race car was still generating wheelspin at 160 km/h with its 5-litre supercharged V16 producing 375 hp, he commissioned ZF in 1935 to come up with a solution.

Comparing limited-slip differentials — SA20

The result was a Gleitsteinsperre — a German term for which there is no direct equivalent, best described as a sliding-block differential. In essence, it is a limited-slip unit based on sliding blocks (“Steine”) that work their way between specially profiled cam rings (“sun gears”). As soon as the wheel speed difference across the axle becomes too great, the mechanism locks up and jumps abruptly from 5% locking to 100%. This principle is harsh in operation and requires periodic overhaul.

Comparing limited-slip differentials — Gleitstein LSD components

Since then, many different designs have been conceived to keep both driven wheels in check, and we notice that our customers often cannot see the wood for the trees amidst inflated marketing claims and scattered forum misinformation.

Comparing limited-slip differentials — Types of Differential Traction 1

What an LSD offers in terms of driving dynamics:

How a limited-slip differential affects the handling characteristics and stability of a car can vary significantly depending on the type of LSD, which is why we created the tables below. With very few exceptions, factory-installed OEM differentials are almost always on the mild side. This means they either cannot or are not set up to lock firmly unless modified afterwards. Manufacturers do this to prevent noises such as chattering in tight corners, at the expense of the stability and traction that a motorsport-grade LSD can provide. This is often presented as an unavoidable trade-off — either one or the other — yet there are limited-slip differentials that are both smooth in operation and deliver exceptional feedback and grip.

Comparing limited-slip differentials — Zc33 24 2
OS Giken Dual Core clutch-type LSD

Predictability – Feedback

A consistent limited-slip differential plays a major role in building driver confidence in the car. A differential that reacts differently in varying situations is much harder to read than one that behaves identically every time. In that respect, an open differential is dreadful because power always takes the path of least resistance, inducing an unpredictable steering effect from the rear axle that continuously shifts depending on input torque at the differential, individual wheel grip, and steering angle.

In principle, Torsen and viscous limited-slip differentials behave in a similar reactive manner: torque, available grip, and steering angle dictate where the power goes, and only once one wheel begins to slip does the differential intervene to correct it.

Comparing limited-slip differentials — Viscous LSD cutaway
GKN Visco-Lok or BMW M Variable LSD.

A mechanical clutch-type (plate) LSD operates differently: it processes the input torque before it reaches the wheels, clamping the clutch packs more or less firmly depending on how much torque enters the differential — directly translating into more or less locking. For the driver, this is far more predictable because the locking force scales directly with throttle input rather than depending on an elusive variable such as surface grip. Combined with a setup firm enough to deliver clear feedback, this provides a substantial boost in driver confidence and traction both at and beyond the limit of tyre grip.

Comparing limited-slip differentials — LTCfig1
Depending on the amount of input torque, the green pressure rings shown in the diagram are forced outward. OS Giken offers an additional tuning parameter here using internal springs that control the opening of the pressure rings.

With an electronically controlled clutch-type differential, this purely mechanical principle no longer applies. Instead, it introduces an array of external parameters into the equation — such as driving mode (Comfort, Sport, etc.), steering angle, brake pressure, throttle pedal position, oil temperature, and more. Consequently, predictability for the driver becomes more elusive and heavily dependent on the manufacturer’s factory calibration.

Comparison Table

In the table below, we outline how the various types of limited-slip differentials stack up against one another. Please note that Table 1 is a subjective evaluation based on our practical motorsport experience and engineering insight.
Rated on a scale from 0 to 10, where 10 is the highest achievable score.

Sper differentieel database

Sper model/FunctiesPerformance/gripDuurzaamheid/revisie kostenSterkte/Tuning geschiktAfwerking/Hoe goed gemaaktVerstelbaarheidInstalleerbaarheid/plug and playPrijs kwaliteit verhoudingSoepelheid van de werkingDriftgeschiktBeschikbaarheid op de markt
Racing diffs lsd conversie1325075238
Oem visco sper244637592?
Oem Torsen3756096854
GKN M variable376609696
Mfactory torsen4767075858
Quaife torsen4988096858
3J NXG5214755865
Wavetrac torsen5988096858
PG torsen4954097857
ZF platensper6556889574
Kaaz7677857687
Mfactory platensper7677865687
Cusco RS7677876687
ATS Metal7677877686
Gripper7697877687
Drexler8699895798
ATS Carbon8898876896
OS Giken superlock TCD9989997987
OS Giken superlock9989998898
Elektronisch rem-sper166009291
E-diff977795698
Open differentieel09440954010
Vastgelast differentieel59930970810
OS Giken dual core8889898681
Eaton Truetrac4978096858

Table 2 provides an overview of the same available limited-slip differentials, assessed strictly on objective functional specifications.

Sper differentieel database 2

Sper model/FunctiesVerstelbaarOnderhoudsvrijReviseerbaarSper bij acceleratieSper bij deceleratieVoordrukNegatieve voordrukBuitenaf verstelbaar
Racing diffs lsd conversieNeeNeeJaJaJaJaNeeNee
Oem visco sperZeer beperktNeeSomsJaJaEen beetjeNeeNee
Oem TorsenNeeJaSomsJaNeeEen beetjeNeeNee
GKN M variableNeeNeeNeeJaJaJaNeeNee
Mfactory torsenNeeJaJaJaNeeJaNeeNee
Quaife torsenNeeJaJaJaNeeJaNeeNee
PG torsenNeeJaJaJaNeeJaNeeNee
Eaton TruetracNeeJaJaJaNeeJaNeeNee
3J NXGJaNeeJaJaJaJaNeeNee
Wavetrac torsenNeeJaJaJaNeeJa, dynamischNeeNee
ZF platensperJaNeeJaJaJaJaNeeNee
KaazJaNeeJaJaJaJaNeeNee
Mfactory platensperJaNeeJaJaJaJa, spiraalveerNeeNee
Cusco RSJaNeeJaJaJaJa, spiraalveerNeeNee
ATS MetalJaNeeJaJaJaJaNeeNee
GripperJaNeeJaJaJaJaNeeNee
DrexlerJaNeeJaJaJaJaNeeOptioneel op sommige modellen
ATS CarbonJaBijnaJaJaJaJaNeeNee
OS Giken superlock TCDJaJaJaJaJaJaJaNee
OS Giken superlockJaJaJaJaJaJaJaNee
Elektronisch rem-sperIn principe welJaNeeJaJaNeeNeeJa
Elektronisch platensper-sper / E-diff / Active M diffJa, actiefBijnaSomsJaJaNeeNeeJa
Open differentieelNeeJaNeeNeeNeeNeeNeeNee
Vastgelast differentieelNeeJaNeeJaJaNeeNeeNee
OS Giken dual coreJaBijnaJaJaJaJaNeeNee

Legend:

Adjustable:

Adjustability is primarily relevant in motorsport, where changing the locking characteristics for wet conditions or varying track surfaces during an event can be crucial. For a road car, internal adjustability has traditionally been less of a factor, as owners are not expected to regularly remove and disassemble their differential to alter the setup.

However, it is vital that your differential is properly configured beforehand, as re-tuning an installed unit to suit your preferences later is labour-intensive. The supplier of the limited-slip differential must therefore possess thorough technical expertise to deliver the unit with the correct setup right out of the box.

Comparing limited-slip differentials — LSD Way new 1

Maintenance-free:

Strictly speaking, no differential is completely maintenance-free. Every unit requires periodic oil changes, although service intervals vary from one design to another. We also frequently see Torsen manufacturers suggest that a clutch-type LSD regularly needs replacement friction plates. In reality, premature plate wear only occurs when the setup is underspecified for the application, allowing the car’s torque to continuously slip through the clutch pack.

Torsen differentials use thrust washers, preload springs, and/or shim plates to keep the worm gears tightly seated inside the carrier housing. Over time, these components wear down as well; once they lose their tight fit and allow play inside the differential casing, the unit begins to clunk on load transitions and stretches the axle shaft oil seals.

Comparing limited-slip differentials — WP 20140314 008 1

Rebuildable:

Can the differential casing be opened up for a refresh, and are spare parts available to replace damaged or worn internals? Even though certain types of limited-slip differentials do not require scheduled overhauls, mechanical failures can always happen, making spare part availability a major advantage.

Comparing limited-slip differentials — Picture 1 1

Locking on acceleration:

Locking under acceleration is usually the primary reason to install a limited-slip differential. Acceleration places the greatest stress on both the differential and the tyres, where the risk of spinning an unloaded wheel is highest.

Comparing limited-slip differentials — Hardeman Motorsport (10)

Locking on deceleration:

Locking under braking and overrun is a somewhat more debated topic, yet it is a proven fact that many racing applications rely heavily on deceleration locking. Deceleration lock provides greater stability and composure when braking into corners, improved control during oversteer situations in both front- and rear-wheel-drive cars, and is particularly crucial in cars with the engine mounted over or behind the rear axle.

Preload:

Preload defines the static initial locking torque of a limited-slip differential. Almost every LSD features dynamic locking behaviour, meaning it applies varying force to keep both driven wheels rotating at the same speed. Preload ensures that under zero-load conditions this dynamic behaviour never drops all the way back to that of an open differential. This prevents all drive torque from being sent to an unloaded wheel with zero resistance. By design, a clutch-type LSD can accommodate significantly higher preload than a Torsen unit.

Comparing limited-slip differentials — Cone LSD diagram

Negative preload:

Negative preload is likewise achieved using internal springs, positioned differently to oppose the opening of the pressure rings. Negative preload counteracts and regulates the dynamic build-up of locking force, resulting in smoother progressive engagement, broader tuning options, and a wider dynamic operating range. Thanks to this finer control, more clutch plates can be employed without immediately creating an overly aggressive differential.

Comparing limited-slip differentials — Giken lsd prod 2 1

Externally adjustable:

Externally adjustable differentials come in several forms. Today, many modern cars leave the factory with differentials equipped with an electric motor that varies the locking force — as seen on the BMW F80 M4, for example — or use electronically or hydraulically controlled clutch packs on the output shafts to achieve active torque vectoring. In motorsport, electronically controlled differentials are prohibited in some series, and they remain a relatively costly option. Manually externally adjustable aftermarket LSDs also exist, though their external adjustment is limited strictly to altering preload.

Comparing limited-slip differentials — 83 2012 bmw m5 fd

If you have any questions, comments, or interest in a limited-slip differential, you can browse our webshop to see the options available for your car, and please feel free to contact us for further information, availability, and installation services.

Need advice or a quote for your differential or chassis?

Send us your VIN and intended use for a tailored workshop quote, or order parts directly at Motorsportparts.nl.